Sugar Salt Sand smash burger - Angus beef, American cheese, Peppajoy aioli, brioche bun
80Smash
Score
Smash Score✅ Certified Smash
Certified Smash Est. 2024

Sugar Salt Sand

Smash Burger
Old Town Fort Collins, Fort Collins, CO · 3 sources scored · Confidence: Low-medium ·Updated September 2026

Fort Collins' hidden smash burger - from the team behind Japango Sushi. Angus beef with housemade Peppajoy aioli on a tropical rooftop that's among the best in Northern Colorado.

Smashburger Old Town Fort Collins Full-Service Restaurant
Visit Website
Smash Score
80 SMASH
SCORE
✅ Certified Smash
3 Sources
Scored Inputs
Low-medium
Confidence
Last calculated September 2026
Algorithm v1.1
The Story

Fort Collins's Certified Smash
A standout built on the smash.

Sugar Salt Sand opened in April 2024 in Old Town Fort Collins, the third concept from the team behind Japango Sushi. The restaurant is a deliberate escape - tropical décor, rooftop deck, and island-inspired cuisine that pulls from the poke, taco, and coastal traditions of warmer climates. The Smash Burger stands out as a signature detour from the island menu: Angus beef with Peppajoy aioli on a brioche bun, served to guests who maybe didn't expect to find a great burger above a sushi restaurant.

The Smash Burger at Sugar Salt Sand comes with a housemade Peppajoy aioli that you won't find anywhere else in Fort Collins - a sauce born from a kitchen that takes tropical flavors seriously. Angus beef, American cheese, and brioche bun are the foundation; the aioli and the element of surprise are what make it stick. At least one guest called it 'insanely delicious' in a place they came for poke - which, in its own way, is the best kind of review a secondary menu item can get.

Score Breakdown

How the 80 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
80
Crowd 45% weight
90
Community 10% weight
77
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
79.83
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
3
Final score formula: 79.83 raw weighted average + +0 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 80.
The Burger

Smash Burger

🥩
Build
Angus beef patty smashed to order, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Peppajoy aioli on a brioche bun
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🍞
Bun
brioche bun
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
lettuce, tomato, onion, and Peppajoy aioli on a brioche bun
💵
Price
$16
💡
Neighborhood
Old Town Fort Collins
🔥
Operation
Full-Service Restaurant
🍔
Established
2024
The Smash Burger at Sugar Salt Sand is a notable menu item in a tropical-forward restaurant known primarily for poke, tacos, and island-inspired fare. The Peppajoy aioli is a housemade condiment unique to the restaurant. At least one TripAdvisor reviewer called the burger 'insanely delicious,' noting surprise given the restaurant's island concept. Angus beef, not wagyu or specialty blend.
Locations

Find Sugar Salt Sand

⭐ Old Town Fort Collins
Sugar Salt Sand
125 S College Ave (Upstairs), Fort Collins, CO 80524
970-413-7435
Mon11am-10pm
Tue11am-10pm
Wed11am-10pm
Thu11am-10pm
Fri11am-11pm
Sat10am-2pm (Brunch) | 4pm-11pm (Dinner)
Sun10am-2pm (Brunch) | 4pm-10pm (Dinner)
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

Surprisingly the burger was insanely delicious.

TripAdvisor · 4.8/5
"

One of the best patios in Northern Colorado - the atmosphere is tropical and the vibe is exactly what you'd hope for.

K99 Northern Colorado
"

Welcoming beautiful space with spacious seating areas. I love looking down at the street.

TripAdvisor · 4.8/5
"

The poke nachos were the best poke nachos we've ever had - a must order.

Google Maps
"

Very friendly, conversational and efficient service - the staff made the whole experience.

TripAdvisor
"

Good food - hot environment. The temperature of the restaurant itself was uncomfortably warm.

TripAdvisor
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

Editorial coverage informs the Smash Score.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
✓One confirmed TripAdvisor reviewer called the burger 'insanely delicious' - a strong signal despite limited editorial coverage
✓Peppajoy aioli is a unique housemade sauce not found at standard smash burger spots
✓Angus beef patty on a brioche bun - quality ingredients relative to a casual-dining price point ($16)
✓Rooftop patio is one of the few in Old Town Fort Collins - strong atmosphere and destination appeal
✓Established concept backed by the experienced Japango Sushi team - kitchen discipline translates across menu
✓Google Maps 4.2/5 across 269 reviews indicates consistently positive guest experience
✓Located in Old Town Fort Collins - high foot traffic, accessible to CSU students and tourists
⚠ Caveats
✗Smash burger is a secondary menu item - not the restaurant's identity or specialty
✗No dedicated smash burger editorial coverage found (no T1, T1.5 sources with burger-specific review)
✗Google Maps rating of 4.2/5 is solid but lower than the 4.5+ typical of top-tier smash burger destinations
✗TripAdvisor only has 5 reviews - very low sample size limits confidence in that platform's 4.8/5
✗Dining room can run warm in summer (noted by at least one TripAdvisor reviewer) - comfort concern during busy service