Hall of Smash Miami · Florida Best Burger Winner 2021 & 2025

Babe's Meat & Counter

Babe's Burger
Palmetto Bay, Miami, Florida · 9 sources scored · Confidence: high
📍 9216 SW 156th St, Miami, FL 33157 · 📞 (786) 429-1315

A 5 oz smashed patty of fresh-ground Prime and Wagyu beef with American cheese, house-made pickles, and sriracha mayo on a Martin's potato roll.

Smashburger Palmetto Bay Butcher Counter Prime + Wagyu
Visit Website
Smash Score
96SMASH
SCORE
Hall of Smash
9 Sources
Scored Inputs
#-- NATIONALLY
National Ranking
#-- IN MIAMI
City Ranking
High
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

COMPETITION RECORD
2021
Miami New Times Best of Miami: Best Burger
Won Best Burger in Miami from Miami New Times Best of Miami annual awards.
2025
Miami New Times Best of Miami: Best Burger
Won Best Burger in Miami again in 2025 with praise for balance and execution.
2022
GMA United States of Burgers
Won the Miami regional round and advanced to the national Top 4 finals.
The Story

Miami's Butcher-Counter Smash Standout.
Prime + Wagyu, Ground In-House.

Babe's Meat & Counter started in 2013 as a farmers market stall at Pinecrest Gardens under the name Babe Froman Fine Sausages, where Jason and Melanie Schoendorfer sold hand-crafted sausages to South Miami-Dade locals. They opened the brick-and-mortar butcher shop and deli in 2018 in Palmetto Bay, building a full-service counter around in-house smoked meats, house-made pickles, and a smashburger that has become one of the most acclaimed in Miami. In March 2026, after eight years operating as a takeout-only counter, they announced an expansion adding approximately 40 seats - the first dining room in the shop's history.

The Babe's Burger is a butcher's burger - the weekly patty blend pulls from whatever Prime and Wagyu cuts are available at the counter that week, ground fresh in-house daily. The fat trimmed from the blend goes into the fryer for the beef-fat fries. The smash is kept slightly thicker than most to let the meat speak, with American cheese, house-made pickles, and sriracha mayo on a Martin's potato roll that steams in the wrapper. Miami New Times has called it the #1 smashburger in Miami and the Best Burger in the city in both 2021 and 2025. The Infatuation gave it 8.6/10: "Every bite is pure, classic burger perfection."

Score Breakdown

How the 96 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
84
Crowd 45% weight
94
Community 10% weight
80
Accolades 10% weight
98
Final score formula: 84.4 raw weighted average + 2.0 qualitative boost + +9.75 competition bonus = 96.
The Burger

Babe's Burger

🥩
Build
5 oz fresh-ground Prime + Wagyu blend smashed but kept slightly thicker for patty character
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🥕
Toppings
House-made pickles and sriracha mayo
🍞
Bun
Martin's potato roll
💵
Price
$17.49
🥓
Notable Side
Beef-fat fries cooked in rendered trim from the daily blend
🍟
Concept
Butcher shop and sandwich counter focused on premium proteins
🍻
Opened
2018
Locations

Location in Miami

Primary Location
Palmetto Bay
9216 SW 156th St
Miami, FL 33157
(786) 429-1315
Opened2018
StatusOpen
Mon-Sat9:00am-5:00pm
Sunday10:00am-3:00pm
Service Notes
Prime + Wagyu Format
Historically takeout-led. Expansion announced March 2026 adds approximately 40 seats for first dine-in service.
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

Every bite is pure, classic burger perfection.

The Infatuation
"

Real burger lovers love Babe's.

Miami New Times
"

The kind of burger you eat in the parking lot because waiting is not an option.

Miami New Times
"

The food at Babe's is all quality and zero flashiness - smashed, but not as thin as most, because you still want to taste the patty they grind fresh themselves.

The Infatuation
"

The Babe's Burger may be simple, but it is seasoned to perfection - the house-made pickles add just enough acidity to the mix.

Miami New Times
"

A fresh-ground Prime and Wagyu blend that changes weekly - the beef today is not the same beef from last Tuesday, and that's the whole point.

Google Reviews
"

This is a butcher shop that also happens to make one of the best burgers in South Florida. The beef-fat fries alone are worth the drive from Miami Beach.

Yelp
"

The potato roll is perfectly steamed by the time you unwrap it, but get there early - they sell out before noon most Saturdays.

Yelp
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
Miami New Times Best of Miami - Best Burger Winner
2025
📋
Miami New Times - #2 of 11 Best Burgers in Miami
2025
📋
Miami New Times - #1 of 7 Best Smash Burgers in Miami
2024
📋
The Infatuation Miami - 8.6/10 Restaurant Review
2022
📋
The Infatuation Miami - Smashburger Power Rankings (#5)
2024
🏆
GMA 'United States of Burgers' - Miami Regional Winner
2022
🏆
Miami New Times Best of Miami - Best Burger Winner
2021
StarChefs 2021 Miami Rising Stars - Butcher Award (Niman Ranch)
2021
📋
Burger Beast - Best Burgers in Miami (December 2025)
2025
📋
South Beach Wine & Food Festival - Exhibitor
2025
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
Two-time Miami New Times Best Burger winner (2021 and 2025).
#1 smashburger in Miami (MNT 2024) and #2 best burger overall (MNT 2025).
The Infatuation 8.6/10 with strong quote-level praise.
GMA Miami regional winner and national Top 4 finalist.
Fresh-ground Prime and Wagyu blend rotated weekly, plus beef-fat fries.
⚠ Caveats
Palmetto Bay location requires a deliberate trip for many Miami visitors.
Historically takeout-only; dine-in expansion status should be verified.
Limited hours and frequent sellouts can reduce availability.
Price has risen materially from earlier years.
Infatuation smashburger ranking places it at #5, indicating strong local competition.