🏆 Hall of Smash Downtown Decatur Est. 2024

Smiley's Burger Club

Double Smash Cheeseburger
Downtown Decatur, Decatur, Georgia · 9 sources scored · Confidence: High
📍 310 E Howard Ave, Decatur, GA 30030

Atlanta's #1 smashburger per The Infatuation, and back-to-back ATL Burger Week champion. The most-awarded smashburger in Decatur made entirely from house-made ingredients.

Smashburger Walk-Up Window House-Made Pickles ATL Burger Week
Visit Website
Smash Score
91SMASH
SCORE
🏆 Hall of Smash
--
National Ranking
--
City Ranking
9 Sources
Scored Inputs
High
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

COMPETITION RECORD
2024
People's Choice
ATL Burger Week - won as a pop-up before opening the permanent Decatur location.
2025
People's Choice
ATL Burger Week - back-to-back champion from the permanent 310 E Howard Ave location.
The Story

Atlanta's two-time ATL Burger Week winner.
From pop-up champion to Decatur anchor.

Smiley's Burger Club started as a Decatur pop-up in early 2024, run by owners Sean Crotty and Ean Camperlengo with a simple mission: make one burger so good it wins Atlanta. It worked. They were crowned ATL Burger Week champions before they even had a permanent address. The brick-and-mortar location at 310 E Howard Ave opened July 20, 2024, across from Kimball House, and quickly became one of Decatur's most-buzzed-about spots.

Every component here is house-made: the dill pickles, the Smiley's sauce, and the proprietary spice blend on the beef. The 2.75-ounce Certified Angus Beef patties get a full-coverage sear that produces crunchy edges and a juicy interior. Cheese is applied via ice cream scoop for even melt, a small choice that reflects how detail-driven this kitchen is.

Score Breakdown

How the 91 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
87
Crowd 45% weight
90
Community 10% weight
80
Accolades 10% weight
48
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
84.45
COMPETITION BONUS
+4.75
TOTAL SOURCES
9
Final score formula: 84.45 raw weighted average + 2.0 qualitative boost + +4.75 competition bonus = 91. The 4.75-point competition bonus reflects ATL Burger Week champion results in 2024 and 2025.
The Burger

Double Smash Cheeseburger

🥩
Build
Double smash, 2x2.75oz Certified Angus Beef patties
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🍞
Bun
Buttered, toasted Engleman's potato roll
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
House-made dill pickles and Smiley's signature sauce
💵
Price
$14.40 (delivery), slightly lower in-store
💡
Neighborhood
Downtown Decatur
🔥
Operation
Walk-up window + outdoor patio
🍔
Established
2024
The double is the move here with full-coverage smashed patties and standout crust. The house-made pickles and proprietary sauce are prepared in-house, and Smiley's has now won ATL Burger Week back-to-back.
Locations

Find Smiley's Burger Club

Primary Location
Smiley's Burger Club
310 E Howard Ave
Decatur, GA 30030
MondayClosed
Tuesday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

The smash burgers here are crunchy edged, juicy, and thoroughly seasoned, so they don't rely on sauces or toppings to add flavor.

The Infatuation Atlanta
"

The smashburger is honed to near perfection -- a 2.75-ounce ball of beef with an excellent fat-to-meat ratio, smashed and cooked on a hot griddle until well-done.

Atlanta Journal-Constitution
"

The burger is crispy-edged, seasoned to the core, and comes with a creamy, tangy sauce, pickles, and melty cheese.

The Infatuation Atlanta
"

The smashed edges on these are perfectly crispy and the cheese, melted on with an ice cream scoop, is the perfect complement.

Burgers, Barbecue and Everything Else
"

The patties develop incredibly crispy, caramelized edges while maintaining a juicy interior that makes every bite memorable.

My Local Nooks
"

Rated 4.5 stars across 366+ Google Reviews.

Google Reviews
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
#1 Best Burger in Atlanta
2024 - Ranked #1 on The Infatuation Atlanta's Best Burgers in Atlanta guide.
🏆
ATL Burger Week Champion
2024 - Won Atlanta Burger Week as a pop-up before permanent opening.
🏆
ATL Burger Week Champion (Repeat)
2025 - Back-to-back ATL Burger Week champion from the Decatur location.
📋
4 Dishes You Have to Try in Atlanta
2024 - Featured by Atlanta Journal-Constitution's monthly must-try dishes column.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
Ranked #1 on The Infatuation's Best Burgers in Atlanta guide.
Back-to-back ATL Burger Week champion in 2024 and 2025.
AJC described the smashburger as near perfection.
House-made pickles, proprietary spice blend, and signature sauce.
⚠ Caveats
Cash only at the walk-up window.
Outdoor and patio seating can be weather-dependent.
Limited parking in a small lot.