87Smash
Score
Score
Smash Score✅ Certified Smash
A hidden gem in rural western Illinois with a small but fiercely loyal following. The smash burgers draw customers from across Mercer County and beyond - and the M80 honey mustard alone is worth the drive.
Photos courtesy of The Midtown Burger Club.
The Midtown Burger Club opened in 2023 in downtown Aledo, Illinois - a tiny Mercer County seat of about 3,500 people - and quickly became the most-talked-about stop in western Illinois for smash burger enthusiasts. Operating out of a counter-service-only storefront on Main Street, the restaurant keeps its hours deliberately short (11am to 2pm, four days a week) and its focus tight: thin smash-style burgers, hand-breaded chicken sandwiches, and Chicago dogs.
The Midtown Classic and Crispy Cheeseburger are the backbone of the menu, featuring the thin smash-style patties the restaurant built its reputation on. What sets the Midtown Burger Club apart in Yelp and Google reviews is the housemade sauce lineup - notably the M80 honey mustard, which regulars single out by name. Reviewers from across western Illinois drive specifically for the burgers, with multiple customers declaring them the best they've ever had.
The Midtown Burger Club has a small, consumer-led source set and no scored editorial coverage. Its score reflects strong diner ratings, but confidence remains low-medium until additional independent sources or a first-party visit are available.
the BEST smash burger I've EVER HAD!! Try all the sauces!! The M80 honey mustard is a must.
Best burgers I've had maybe ever??? Food is delicious.
My wife, who is NOT a burger person, loves this stuff.
I love the small town vibe, delicious food, their specials are always awesome.
Amazing smash burgers, friendly staff. Amazing food, fast service, and great prices.
All the food is excellent but a few of us are partial to the Chicago Dogs!