Certified Smash Westwood Center Est. 2020

The Peanut Gallery

Shaolin Burger
Westwood Center, Lake Forest, Illinois · Counter-service burger and ice cream concept · 7 sources scored
📍 588 N Western Ave, Lake Forest, IL 60045 · 📞 (224) 544-5442

Lake Forest counter-service burger and ice cream spot from the team behind The Gallery. Signature Shaolin Burger layers cheddar, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and black garlic aioli over double smash patties on brioche.

Smashburger Westwood Center Counter Service Black Garlic Aioli
Visit Website
Smash Score
81SMASH
SCORE
Certified Smash
#-- Nationally
National Ranking
#-- in Lake Forest
City Ranking
7 Sources
Scored Inputs
Medium-high
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

The Story

Lake Forest's Westwood Center
James Beard-pedigreed smash spot.

The Peanut Gallery opened in December 2019 in Lake Forest's Westwood Center as a deliberate counterpoint to fine dining. Co-owners Cecilia Lanyon and James Beard-nominated chef Dominic Zumpano, who together run The Gallery and produce the Revelry Food & Wine Festival, built a neighborhood burger destination centered on counter service, hand-cut fries, and broad local accessibility.

The Shaolin Burger is the flagship build: double smash patties with cheddar, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and black garlic aioli on brioche. The black garlic aioli is the standout differentiator, adding depth that separates it from standard diner-style smash profiles.

At 81, the score reflects strong consumer-platform consensus, a high-signal LTH Forum thread explicitly calling out the smash execution, and meaningful local editorial/community validation, despite no Tier 1 major food-publication coverage yet.

Score Breakdown

How the 81 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
77
Crowd 45% weight
97
Community 10% weight
83
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
81.13
QUALITATIVE BOOST
+0
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
Final score formula: 81.13 raw weighted average + 0 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 81.
The Burger

Shaolin Burger

🥩
Build
Double smash patties cooked hard on a flat-top for crispy edges and juicy centers
🧀
Cheese
Cheddar
🍞
Bun
Brioche bun
🥕
Toppings
Caramelized onions, mushrooms, black garlic aioli
💵
Price
$10.25
🍽
Notes
Price confirmed around $10.25 in 2025 community sources; verify current Square ordering menu for live pricing.
🔥
Concept
Fast-casual counter-service burger and ice cream restaurant
📅
Opened
2020
Location

Find The Peanut Gallery

⭐ Original Location - Westwood Center
The Peanut Gallery
588 N Western Ave, Lake Forest, IL 60045
(224) 544-5442
MondayClosed
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday11am-8pm
Thursday11am-8pm
Friday11am-8pm
Saturday11am-8pm
SundayClosed
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

The Peanut Gallery = Awesome Smashed Burgers in Lake Forest.

LTH Forum
"

No other burger comes close. Best taste and nostalgic burger joint feel! The combination of specialty topping and high quality meat.

Lake Forest-Lake Bluff Patch
"

Made-to-order smashburger patties expertly crafted to achieve a delightful combination of flavor and texture, featuring crisp edges and juicy interiors.

Google Reviews · 4.8/5
"

Not too big or small, a little greasy and oh so tasty.

Lake Forest-Lake Bluff Patch
"

People could enjoy delicious food and raising money for a good cause - it requires a battle between the Lake Forest Police and Fire departments.

Fox 32 Chicago
"

The Shaolin burger is topped with cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and black garlic aioli - all were good.

LTH Forum
"

Food came very quick and was awesome!! We would definitely eat here again, if ever back in town!

TripAdvisor · 5.0/5
"

A narrow hole in the wall type of place. You place your order at the counter, pay, get a number, and grab a table.

LTH Forum
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
Best Burger in Lake Forest Area - Readers' Pick
2021 · Won Patch reader survey with nearly 30% of votes.
Service Superstar Award - National French Fry Day
2024 · McCain Foods and Chef Beau MacMillan recognition.
📋
LTH Forum - Great Neighborhood Restaurant
2025 · Featured in 'Awesome Smashed Burgers in Lake Forest' thread.
📋
Revelry Food & Wine Festival - Founding Partner Restaurant
2022 · Ownership team co-produces the annual Lake Forest event.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
James Beard Award-nominated chef pedigree supports unusually strong execution for a fast-casual format.
4.8 Google rating and 4.7 Restaurant Guru rating (185 reviews) indicate strong cross-platform consistency.
LTH Forum specifically called out 'Awesome Smashed Burgers' in Lake Forest.
Shaolin Burger's black garlic aioli is a genuine profile differentiator.
Strong value at roughly $10.25 for a double smash build from a chef-led kitchen.
⚠ Caveats
No Tier 1 major food publication coverage found yet (Infatuation/Eater/Time Out/Tribune/Chicago Magazine).
Hours are limited to Wednesday-Saturday, reducing access windows.
Counter-service format with minimal indoor seating can limit full dine-in consistency.
TripAdvisor signal is thin (single review), so platform variance risk remains.
Yelp rating was not confirmed in-source during research.