Cryin' Johnny smash burger with caramelized onion and American cheese at Ducky's at the Pearl
85Smash
Score
Smash Score✓ Certified Smash
Certified Smash Est. 2025

Ducky's at the Pearl

Cryin' Johnny Burger (Double)
Downtown Fort Wayne / The Pearl, Fort Wayne, IN · 3 sources scored · Confidence: Low Medium ·Updated August 2026

Downtown Fort Wayne's bowling-and-burgers concept from Te Gusto Hospitality. Order the Cryin' Johnny swim style - beer cheese, caramelized onions, and a homemade bun that reviewers call heavenly.

Smashburger Downtown Fort Wayne / The Pearl Dine-InTakeout
Visit Website
Smash Score
85 SMASH
SCORE
✓ Certified Smash
3 Sources
Scored Inputs
Low Medium
Confidence
Last calculated August 2026
Algorithm v1.1
The Story

Fort Wayne's Certified Smash
A local smash worth knowing.

Ducky's at the Pearl opened in April 2025 as the anchor dining concept for The Pearl, downtown Fort Wayne's mixed-use development. Te Gusto Hospitality - the team behind Mercado on the Landing and Papi's Pizza - built Ducky's around a deceptively simple idea: pair eight lanes of duckpin bowling with a scratch kitchen that takes the food seriously. The smash burger is the centerpiece, named after owner Johnny Perez in a nod to the restaurant's personality.

The Cryin' Johnny Double stacks two smash patties with caramelized onion, fried mustard, and American cheese - an elevated pub build that earns its name. The 'swim style' finishing move (drenching the burger in house beer cheese) is the signature recommendation and the modification reviewers consistently call out. Multiple diners have singled out the house-made bun as the detail that separates Ducky's from the standard bar-burger crowd.

Score Breakdown

How the 85 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
0
Crowd 45% weight
85
Community 10% weight
0
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
85.33
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
3
Final score formula: 85.33 raw weighted average + +0 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 85.
The Burger

Cryin' Johnny Burger (Double)

🥩
Build
Two smash patties
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🍞
Bun
Not specified
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
fried mustard, American cheese. Served with one side (fries or chips). Order it 'swim style' to get it drenched in house beer cheese.
💵
Price
$18
💡
Neighborhood
Downtown Fort Wayne / The Pearl
🔥
Operation
Restaurant
🍔
Established
2025
Named after owner Johnny Perez ('Cryin' Johnny'), this double smash is the restaurant's signature item. The caramelized onion and fried mustard build puts it in the pub-burger tradition - less classic, more elevated. The 'swim style' upgrade (beer cheese) is the finishing move that most reviewers call out specifically, and it's the way the house recommends you order it.
Locations

Find Ducky's at the Pearl

⭐ Downtown Fort Wayne / The Pearl
Ducky's at the Pearl
249 Pearl St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802
(260) 205-8639
Mon4pm-10pm
Tue4pm-10pm
Wed4pm-10pm
Thu4pm-10pm
Fri11am-12am
Sat11am-12am
Sun11am-9pm
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

The smash patty and the warm homemade bun - heavenly. Paired perfectly with crispy fries.

Google Maps
"

The burger was cooked perfectly and the toppings were delicious. Make it swim - trust me.

Google Maps
"

10/10 recommend the food and drinks! The service was fast and friendly.

Facebook
"

Such a fun environment and family friendly. Very friendly and attentive staff.

Google Maps
"

Fresh and crispy fries. Their fries are consistently good.

Google Maps
"

We want it to be a place where you can bring your kids to play, but still feel it's of a high enough caliber that you want to hang out and eat there yourself.

The Local FW
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

🏆
Visit Fort Wayne Best Burgers Guide
2026 - Visit Fort Wayne published a Best Burgers in Fort Wayne guide on January 2, 2026. Ducky's is NOT included on this list. Notable gap - restaurant opened April 2025 and had been operating ~9 months before the guide was published.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
✓Signature Cryin' Johnny burger named after owner Johnny Perez - storytelling baked into the menu
✓'Swim style' beer cheese option transforms the burger into a distinctive pub experience
✓Homemade bun called out specifically by multiple reviewers as elevated above standard bar buns
✓Google 4.4/5 on 104 reviews - above-average for a new downtown entertainment concept
✓Family-friendly concept with 8 duckpin bowling lanes - natural upsell to multi-visit occasions
✓Late-night hours (Fri/Sat until midnight) serving Fort Wayne's underserved nightlife dining window
⚠ Caveats
✗Yelp rating (3.9/5) trails Google (4.4/5) - suggests some inconsistency reviewers want to flag
✗Only 19 Yelp reviews and 5 Facebook reviews - extremely limited statistical base outside Google
✗Journal Gazette Dining Out column (Ryan DuVall) has not reviewed Ducky's - most important editorial signal remains absent
✗Not included on Visit Fort Wayne's Best Burgers guide (January 2026) - notable omission
✗Entertainment-venue context (bowling, tiki cocktails, TVs) may dilute focus on burger quality