Aggressive Double Smash burger at Bun's n Shakes in New Brunswick, NJ
84Smash
Score
Smash Score✓ Certified Smash
Certified Smash Est. 2022

Bun's n Shakes

Aggressive Double Smash
Downtown New Brunswick, New Brunswick, NJ · 3 sources scored · Confidence: Low-Medium ·Updated August 2026

New Brunswick's destination smash burger - halal-certified, double-smashed patties with serious crust and texture, and milkshakes to match.

Smashburger Downtown New Brunswick SmashburgerHalal
Visit Website →
Smash Score
84 SMASH
SCORE
✓ Certified Smash
3 Sources
Scored Inputs
Low-Medium
Confidence
Last calculated August 2026
Algorithm v1.1
The Story

New Brunswick's Halal Smashburger Destination
Crisp edges, big flavor, and a neighborhood following.

Bun's n Shakes opened in 2022 in downtown New Brunswick, NJ, steps from the Rutgers University campus on Church Street. The concept is straightforward: halal-certified smash burgers, Nashville hot chicken, and thick milkshakes in a fast-casual counter-service format. In a college town where the food options tend toward the chains, Bun's n Shakes built a following by doing the smash technique properly - hard-pressed on a flat-top, caramelized crust, no shortcuts.

The Aggressive Double Smash is the calling card - two halal beef patties smashed hard against the griddle to create lacy, crunchy-edged patties with full-coverage caramelized sear, layered with American cheese, shaved onions, pickles, and house OG sauce on a soft potato bun. Food content creator duo DevourPower (2.9M TikTok) named it one of their all-time favorite burger joints after multiple visits. The halal certification and Rutgers proximity have made it a regional destination drawing diners from across Central Jersey.

Score Breakdown

How the 84 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
84
Crowd 45% weight
86
Community 10% weight
85
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
83.87
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
3
Final score formula: 83.87 raw weighted average + +0 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 84.
The Burger

Aggressive Double Smash

🥩
Build
Double smash, halal beef patties
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🍞
Bun
Toasted potato bun
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
shaved onions, American cheese, pickles, OG sauce on a soft toasted potato bun
💵
Price
Price not listed
💡
Neighborhood
Downtown New Brunswick
🔥
Operation
Fast-Casual Restaurant
🍔
Established
2022
The Aggressive Double Smash is the burger that earned Bun's n Shakes its regional reputation - featured prominently in food media and on DevourPower's 'favorites' list. The hard smash technique produces a lacy, crunchy edge on every patty, giving it the textural contrast that separates a real smashburger from a pressed patty. Halal-certified beef.
Locations

Find Bun's n Shakes

⭐ Downtown New Brunswick
Bun's n Shakes
112 Church St
New Brunswick, NJ 08901
(732) 317-4112
Mon11am-10pm
Tue11am-10pm
Wed11am-10pm
Thu11am-10pm
Fri11am-11pm
Sat12pm-11pm
Sun12pm-9pm
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

This is one of our favorite burger joints ever! We went ALL OUT at @BunsNShakesNJ in New Brunswick, NJ!

DevourPower
"

We cannot get enough of @BunsNShakesNJ.

DevourPower
"

Fast-food energy with Michelin-level obsession over texture. Chaos in the best possible way.

Ever After in the Woods
"

Crispy, lacy edges on the patties, melty cheese, and a soft glossy bun - the double smash burger absolutely delivered.

Google Reviews
"

The spot has a chill, no-nonsense burger joint vibe where the focus is clearly on doing smash burgers right - great service, great burger.

Google Reviews
"

If you're in New Brunswick and craving a proper smash burger, this place definitely hits the spot.

Google Reviews
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
No formal awards or list inclusions yet
This page will be updated as new recognition is published.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
✓Hard smash technique produces lacy, crunchy-edged patties with full-coverage caramelized sear
✓Halal-certified beef with documented food media endorsement from major NYC content creators
✓Strong crowd consensus: 4.3/5 across 467 Google reviews
✓Featured multiple times by DevourPower (2.9M TikTok) as 'one of our favorite burger joints ever'
✓Extended late-night hours Friday and Saturday (open until 11pm) - unusual for the category
✓Creative menu extensions: SmashMac, Smashcheetos, loaded fries, Doritos builds
✓Milkshake program (Lotus Biscoff, Nutella, Twinkies) complements the burger menu
⚠ Caveats
✗Owner identity and founding story not publicly documented - limits editorial storytelling depth
✗Aggressive Double Smash price unconfirmed; menu pricing inconsistent across third-party sources
✗Limited editorial media coverage - no MyCentralJersey.com, NJ.com, or Infatuation features found
✗Yelp rating not confirmed (70 reviews found, page blocked)