Solid Smash Est. 2011

Tucker's Onion Burgers

Double Onion Burger with Cheese
Uptown 23rd, Oklahoma City, OK · 8 sources scored · Confidence: High
📍 324 NW 23rd St, Oklahoma City, OK 73103

Oklahoma City's definitive premium onion smashburger — where 1920s roadside diner tradition meets Creekstone Farms beef. Ranked #2 of the best burgers in OKC by 405 Magazine.

Smashburger Uptown 23rd Onion BurgerFlat-TopOKC Classic
Visit Website
Smash Score
77 SMASH
SCORE
👍 Solid Smash
8 Sources
Scored Inputs
High
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

The Story

Oklahoma City's onion burger revival
A premium take on a state classic.

Tucker's Onion Burgers opened in 2011 in Oklahoma City's Uptown 23rd district, founded by Sean Ray, Heather Paul, and Keith Paul of A Good Egg Dining Group — and named after the Pauls' English Mastiff. The concept was simple and deliberate: bring the Depression-era Oklahoma onion burger tradition back as a premium experience, using Creekstone Farms all-natural beef and buns from Prairie Thunder Baking Co. rather than commodity inputs. It was Oklahoma City's first premium interpretation of the style that originated in El Reno roadside cafes in the 1920s.

The Oklahoma-style technique is everything: hand-shredded fresh white onions are piled high on the raw beef ball, then smashed into the patty with a spatula on a flat-top griddle. The onions don't go on as a topping — they are pressed into the meat and caramelize as the patty cooks, fusing sweetness, char, and beef fat into a single inseparable layer. Tucker's does this with Creekstone Farms Black Angus beef, and serves it on a toasted Prairie Thunder bun with American cheese and classic mustard-and-pickle build. Order the double.

Smash Atlas Context Note

Oklahoma City is a strong regional burger market without the same volume of current national review coverage as larger metros. Tucker's score leans on local editorial history, strong consumer aggregates, and its role as a premium revival of the Oklahoma onion burger tradition.

Score Breakdown

How the 77 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
78
Crowd 45% weight
89
Community 10% weight
83
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
75.17
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
8
Final score formula: 75.17 raw weighted average + +2.00 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 77.
The Burger

Double Onion Burger with Cheese

🥩
Build
Two thin Creekstone Farms Black Angus patties smashed on a flat-top with shredded white onions
🧀
Cheese
American cheese on each patty
🍞
Bun
Toasted Prairie Thunder bun from Oklahoma City
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
Mustard, pickles, ketchup on request, caramelized smashed-in white onions
💵
Price
$11.95
💡
Neighborhood
Uptown 23rd
🔥
Operation
Dedicated Onion Burger Restaurant
🍔
Established
2011
The double is the definitive Tucker's order and the one reviewers consistently recommend. The Oklahoma-style onion burger technique — smashing raw onions directly into the patty during cooking — is the entire concept. The onions caramelize and fuse with the beef, delivering depth and sweetness that a separately-cooked topping never achieves. Premium Creekstone Farms sourcing and Prairie Thunder buns distinguish Tucker's from casual onion burger joints.
Locations

Find Tucker's Onion Burgers

⭐ Original Flagship
Tucker's Onion Burgers - Uptown 23rd
324 NW 23rd St, Oklahoma City, OK 73103
Mon11am-9pm
Tue11am-9pm
Wed11am-9pm
Thu11am-9pm
Fri11am-9pm
Sat11am-9pm
Sun11am-9pm
Oklahoma City Location
Tucker's Onion Burgers - N Classen Blvd
5740 N Classen Blvd, Oklahoma City, OK 73118
Oklahoma City Location
Tucker's Onion Burgers - N May Ave
15001 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73134
Oklahoma City Location
Tucker's Onion Burgers - N Rockwell Ave
12215 N Rockwell Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73162
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

Tucker's employs the traditional Oklahoma-style onion burger technique, placing thin white onion strings directly on the patty before smashing. This method loosens the ground meat, fusing onion flavor with savory juiciness from the Creekstone Farms black angus beef.

405 Magazine
"

This burger is a must if you visit Oklahoma! It was juicy, flavorful and seasoned beautifully. The cheese was totally melted and the onions were perfectly cooked — there are a lot of them.

TC Burger Blog · 4.5/5
"

Tucker's Onion Burgers represents a newer interpretation of the classic Oklahoma burger, elevating the traditional recipe while maintaining the core onion burger concept.

405 Magazine
"

Delicious homemade burgers in a classic, Oklahoma diner atmosphere. Fresh, juicy onion burgers — the fries pair perfectly with anything on the menu.

OKMag
"

These onion burgers are one of my favorite burger types and Tucker's does them right. They smush down the meat and brown it well to a bit crispy.

TripAdvisor
"

My husband had the Mother Tucker: one pound of ground beef grilled with onions. He said 'this is the best burger I ever had!'

TripAdvisor
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
#2 405 Magazine — The Metro's 10 Most Bodacious Burgers
2013 - #2 on 405 Magazine's definitive OKC best burgers list — the most authoritative local editorial burger list.
📋
405 Magazine — The Evolution of Oklahoma's Onion Burgers
2024 - Featured as the premium modern interpretation of Oklahoma's signature onion burger tradition.
TripAdvisor — #3 Quick Bites in Oklahoma City
2026 - Ranked #3 of 143 Quick Bites restaurants in Oklahoma City based on traveler reviews.
📋
TasteAtlas — Recommended by Thrillist and 18 food critics
2024 - TasteAtlas notes Tucker's onion burger is recommended by Thrillist and 17 additional food critics. Specific Thrillist article not directly confirmed.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
Oklahoma-style onion burger technique — onions smashed directly into beef during cooking — delivers caramelized flavor impossible to replicate with separately-cooked onions
Premium sourcing: Creekstone Farms all-natural Black Angus beef and Prairie Thunder Baking Co. buns distinguish Tucker's from commodity-sourced competitors
Ranked #2 on 405 Magazine's 'Most Bodacious Burgers' list — OKC's most authoritative editorial burger ranking
Ranked #3 of 143 Quick Bites in Oklahoma City on TripAdvisor with 218+ reviews
4.6/5 Google rating across 2,900+ reviews is exceptionally strong for a burger-specific restaurant
Cult following since 2011 with multiple expanded OKC locations, all holding strong ratings
Burger is culturally resonant — Tucker's is credited with elevating Oklahoma's signature food tradition to a premium dining experience
⚠ Caveats
Two of three T1 editorial sources are from 2011-2013 — the burger's current standing is validated primarily by strong consumer ratings rather than recent food press
TC Burger Blog (2019) review noted 'a lot of onions' which some guests may find overwhelming
No recent major national editorial coverage confirmed (Food & Wine, Southern Living, Eater, Bon Appétit) despite being a strong local and regional institution
Phone number for 23rd Street flagship not confirmed in public records