Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.
West Bend's highest-rated burger, featured in Wisconsin's Best Burger Elite Eight in its first year. Retro arcade atmosphere, double smash patties, and a full creative burger lineup.
Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.
Game Over opened May 3, 2025 in downtown West Bend at 228 N. 6th Ave., taking over the former 6th Ave. Bar & Grill space under owner Wesley Feest and head chef Nate Mankowski. The concept is a retro 80s/90s arcade bar and grill where the games and the smashburgers get equal billing — and less than a year after opening, the burgers earned a spot in Wisconsin's Best Burger Elite Eight.
The menu centers on a lineup of smashed double-patty burgers — The Homie (classic double smash with house sauce), The G Thang (elevated build), Frenchie, Fiesta, and Cowabunga — each leaning into a theme without losing sight of the fundamental smash technique. The Wisconsin Beef Council recognized Game Over's burger as one of the eight best in the state in its 2026 contest, a significant achievement for a restaurant open barely a year.
Game Over is an arcade-themed bar and grill rather than a dedicated burger-only shop. The Smash Score reflects the strength of The Homie and the burger program specifically, with a medium-high confidence level because the restaurant is still new and long-term review history is limited.
Game Over is among Wisconsin's best burgers, selected as one of eight finalists in the Wisconsin Beef Council's 2026 Best Burger Contest.
Game Over's burger is among the best in Wisconsin, earning a spot in the Elite Eight of the Wisconsin Beef Council's Best Burger competition.
The new gaming-themed restaurant and arcade in downtown West Bend brings a full burger menu anchored by smashed patties to a space that celebrates 80s and 90s nostalgia.
Rated 4.6/5 across 153 Google reviews — and ranked #1 of 102 restaurants in West Bend on Restaurant Guru.
4.6 stars on DoorDash from 200+ delivery ratings.