Certified SmashEst. 2020

Best Intentions

Best Intentions Smashburger
Logan Square, Chicago, Illinois·6 sources scored·Confidence: High
📍 3281 W Armitage Ave, Chicago, IL 60647·📞 (312) 818-1254

Dive bar meets fancy cocktail bar in Logan Square. Signature $6 smashburger with house-made Dutch curry mayonnaise, mustard-onion griddle technique, and Land 'o Lakes white American cheese.

SmashburgerLogan SquareDive BarCocktail Bar
Visit Website
Smash Score
84SMASH
SCORE
Certified Smash
6 Sources
Scored Inputs
High
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.2

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

The Story

Logan Square's Dive-Bar Classic.
A $6 Smash With Serious Craft.

Best Intentions opened as a neighborhood dive bar on Logan Square's Armitage Avenue in 2020. After a three-year closure, it reopened in May 2023 and quickly regained momentum with a hybrid identity: authentic dive atmosphere paired with carefully built cocktails and unexpectedly strong food.

Its smashburger is built on mustard-and-onion griddle technique, Land 'o Lakes white American cheese, dill pickles, and a soft Martin's potato roll. The defining flavor is house-made Dutch curry mayonnaise, which gives the burger a profile that's different from most top Chicago smash spots.

Editorial and community sources consistently frame it as one of Chicago's better burger values: $6 for a highly praised burger in a high-demand neighborhood market.

Context Note

Best Intentions is primarily a bar concept. The Smash Score reflects the quality of the featured smashburger specifically, not a burger-only restaurant model.

Score Breakdown

How the 84 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
84
Crowd 45% weight
85
Community 10% weight
83
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
82.04
COMPETITION BONUS
+0.0
SOURCES SCORED
6
Final score formula: 82.04 raw weighted average + 1.5 qualitative boost + 0.0 competition bonus = 84.
The Burger

Best Intentions Smashburger

🥩
Build
Single smashed beef patty griddled with mustard and onions
🧀
Cheese
Land 'o Lakes white American
🍞
Bun
Martin's potato roll
🥕
Toppings
Dutch curry mayo, dill pickles
💵
Price
$6.00
🍪
Signature
House-made Dutch curry mayonnaise
🍻
Concept
Dive bar + cocktail bar
📅
Reopened
May 2023
Remarkable value profile in Chicago's premium burger market. The burger can also be ordered as a baker's dozen (13 burgers) for $72.
Location

Find Best Intentions

⭐ Original Location
Logan Square
3281 W Armitage Ave, Chicago, IL 60647
(312) 818-1254
StatusOpen
ReopenedMay 2023
HoursCheck website
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

I certainly didn't expect to find the second best cheeseburger in the Chicago area in a fancy cocktail bar.

TripAdvisor
"

After a three-year hiatus, Logan Square's Best Intentions quietly reopened in 2023. Their $6 smashburger is the ideal bar snack.

The Infatuation Chicago · 8.4/10
"

Best Intentions shows Midwestern pride with one of the best burgers in the city. This bar was nominated for a James Beard Award in 2025.

Postcard Travel Guide
"

Affordable $6 burger widely praised as amazing and fantastic. Retains authentic dive bar charm with broken-in vibe.

Chicago Cocktail Compass
"

The burgers and fries are delicious, with the smash burger being particularly praised. Burgers priced at only $6 each are phenomenal.

Restaurant Ji
"

The smash burger was delicious. Simple no frills burger and drinks. Don't sleep on the burger and fries if you need a snack.

Google Reviews · 4.6/5
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

North America's 50 Best Bars 2024
Featured by major cocktail bar ranking.
James Beard Awards 2025 (Nomination)
Hospitality recognition for bar program and concept.
📋
25 Quintessential Bars That Make Chicago What It Is
Included by The Infatuation (2024).
📋
Best Restaurants in Logan Square
Neighborhood guide inclusion (2024).
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
Exceptional value at $6 in a premium market segment.
Dutch curry mayonnaise creates a signature profile distinct from peer burgers.
Strong editorial signal from The Infatuation and Postcard.
High consumer validation across Google and TripAdvisor.
Institutional credibility from North America's 50 Best Bars and James Beard nomination.
⚠ Caveats
Single-patty build may feel light versus larger multi-patty competitors.
Burger is part of a broader bar concept, not a dedicated burger operation.
No burger-specific competition wins listed in current dataset.
Limited seating format can reduce accessibility at peak hours.