Pop's Double Smashburger at Bitter Pops
87Smash
Score
Smash ScoreCertified Smash
Certified SmashLakeview / Roscoe Village BorderEst. 2016

Bitter Pops

Pop's Double Smashburger
Lakeview / Roscoe Village border, Chicago, Illinois·6 sources scored·Confidence: Medium-high·Updated April 2026

A craft beer bottle shop's secret weapon: Pop's Double Smashburger features lacy-edged patties, Courage Lager caramelized onions, and "dynamite" Honeycup Dijonnaise. Chicago Magazine ranked it #6 in the city.

SmashburgerTaproom + Bottle ShopChicago Magazine #6House Beer Onions
Smash Score
87SMASH
SCORE
Certified Smash
#-- Nationally
National Ranking
#-- in Chicago
City Ranking
6 Sources
Scored Inputs
Medium-high
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1
The Story

From Beer Shop to Burger Standout.
A taproom kitchen that became a Chicago contender.

Bitter Pops began in 2016 as a craft beer bottle shop on Lincoln Avenue in Lakeview, founded by Mike Jorndt after 20 years in marketing. The concept grew out of a newsletter and expanded into a larger taproom plus kitchen footprint.

In May 2021, opening chef Kevin McCormick launched the full food program. Pop's Double Smashburger emerged as the signature, combining ultrathin lacy-edge patties with American cheese, Courage Lager caramelized onions, and Honeycup Dijonnaise.

Chicago Magazine featured the burger in 2023 and then ranked it #6 citywide in 2024, while The Party Cut called it one of the best burgers in Chicago.

Context Note
Bitter Pops is primarily a craft beer taproom and bottle shop. The Smash Score here evaluates the burger program specifically within that broader concept.
Score Breakdown

How the 87 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
87
Crowd 45% weight
90
Community 10% weight
87
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
85.52
QUALITATIVE BOOST
+1.5
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
Final score formula: 85.52 raw weighted average + 2 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 87.
The Burger

Pop's Double Smashburger

🥩
Build
Two ultrathin smashed beef patties with lacy edges
🧀
Cheese
American
🍞
Bun
Toasted potato bun
🥕
Toppings
Courage Lager caramelized onions, Honeycup Dijonnaise, house pickles (side), fries included
💵
Price
$12.99
📍
Neighborhood
Lakeview / Roscoe Village border
🔥
Operation
Craft beer taproom + bottle shop with full kitchen
🍻
Established
2016 (kitchen 2021)
The Dijonnaise is repeatedly highlighted as the flavor anchor, while beer-based onion prep gives this burger a true house identity.
Also on the Menu
Locations

Find Bitter Pops

⭐ Primary Location
Bitter Pops
3357 N Lincoln Ave
Chicago, IL 60657
(773) 857-7677
MondayClosed
Tuesday11:30am-9pm
Wednesday11:30am-9pm
Thursday11:30am-10pm
Friday11:30am-10pm
Saturday11:30am-10pm
Sunday11:30am-8pm
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

Imagine an elevated patty melt served on a potato bun, only with edges so gloriously brittle you'd swear every one was ironed.

Chicago Magazine
"

This burger wowed me, and it won't leave you hungry. The melty cheese is just right, as are the onions and the Dijonnaise.

Chicago Magazine
"

Bitter Pops double smashburger ($12.99) is, in my opinion, one of the best burgers in Chicago.

The Party Cut
"

They smash 'em good at Bitter Pops: one part takeout beer emporium, one part family-friendly taproom.

Chicago Magazine
"

The smash burger here is pretty bomb... very righteous burger in a land of too many average burgers.

Yelp
"

Be sure to order the double smashburger, one of the best smashburgers in Chicago.

TripAdvisor
"

The burger is so good that you don't need ketchup or relish. The patties are crispy on the edges.

Google Reviews
"

The food quality has remained excellent over the years. The burger wowed me.

The Party Cut
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
The Smash Burger You Need to Try Next
2023 · Chicago Magazine feature
📋
The Great Chicago Burger Quest (#6)
2024 · Chicago Magazine ranked list
📋
Chicago's Best Smashburger (Video Feature)
Number Six With Cheese (Facebook)
📋
Savor Chicago: Unique Burgers You Must Try (#1)
2024 · Boricuas Living Abroad
📋
Oktoberfest at Bitter Pops Feature
2024 · Chicago Food Magazine
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
✓Strong Tier 1 coverage from Chicago Magazine, including a citywide #6 ranking.
✓The Party Cut explicitly calls it one of Chicago's best burgers.
✓Courage Lager caramelized onions create a true house signature.
✓Honeycup Dijonnaise gives the burger a distinctive flavor identity.
✓High consumer platform signals, led by Google at 4.8.
✓Seasonal smash variants show consistent kitchen creativity.
⚠ Caveats
✗Not currently included in The Infatuation Chicago smashburger list.
✗Kitchen service is closed Mondays, reducing access windows.
✗Burger coverage can be overshadowed by the beer program identity.
✗No confirmed competition win bonus in the current score model.
✗Yelp star rating remains estimated and should be confirmed directly.