Parson's double smash cheeseburger with two patties and potato chips
77Smash
Score
Smash Score👍 Solid Smash
Solid Smash Est. 2013

Parson's Chicken & Fish

Double Smash Burger
Logan Square, Chicago, IL · 5 sources scored · Confidence: Medium ·Updated July 2026

The Double Smash Burger from a Chicago institution - Slagel Farms beef, Smokey 1000 Island, cornmeal bun. The same team behind Longman & Eagle, on one of the city's great patios.

Smashburger Logan Square Dine-InTakeout
Visit Website
Smash Score
77 SMASH
SCORE
👍 Solid Smash
5 Sources
Scored Inputs
Medium
Confidence
Last calculated July 2026
Algorithm v1.1
The Story

Logan Square's Smashburger Entry
A focused look at the featured smash.

Parson's Chicken & Fish opened at 2952 W Armitage Avenue in Logan Square on May 15, 2013, founded by Pete Toalson, artist Cody Hudson, and Mode Carpentry co-founders Jon Martin and Robert McAdams - the same team behind the Michelin-starred gastropub Longman & Eagle. Opening chef Hunter Moore brought experience from Avec and Girl & the Goat to build a menu centered on Southern-style fried chicken and fish in a space that quickly became one of Chicago's most beloved patio destinations. The Double Smash Burger arrived later, a recent addition to the lineup that carries the restaurant's local sourcing philosophy forward with Slagel Farms beef.

The Double Smash Burger stands apart from Chicago's smash market through its ingredient sourcing: Slagel Farms beef patties - smashed and seared for a full-coverage crust - alongside American cheese, griddled onion, kosher dill pickles, and the restaurant's Smokey 1000 Island sauce on a cornmeal bun. The Slagel Family Farm in Fairbury, IL, is the same farm that supplies The Loyalist and Au Cheval, bringing a richer fat distribution to the patty. The cornmeal bun adds a subtle texture and flavor note that sets the build apart from the standard brioche.

Smash Atlas Context Note

Parson's Chicken & Fish serves a broader menu; this assessment focuses specifically on Double Smash Burger.

Score Breakdown

How the 77 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
73
Crowd 45% weight
83
Community 10% weight
0
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
75.62
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
5
Final score formula: 75.62 raw weighted average + +1.5 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 77.
The Burger

Double Smash Burger

🥩
Build
Two smashed Slagel Farms beef patties
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🍞
Bun
Smokey 1000 Island sauce on a cornmeal bun
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
American cheese, onion, kosher dill pickles, Smokey 1000 Island sauce
💵
Price
$15.95
💡
Neighborhood
Logan Square
🔥
Operation
Restaurant
🍔
Established
2013
Parson's Double Smash Burger uses Slagel Farms beef - the same premium Illinois farm that supplies The Loyalist and Au Cheval - giving it a richer fat content than commodity blends. The Smokey 1000 Island is a house-made sauce, and the cornmeal bun is a distinctive alternative to the standard brioche found throughout the Chicago smash market.
Locations

Find Parson's Chicken & Fish

⭐ Logan Square (Primary / Original)
Logan Square (Primary / Original)
2952 W Armitage Ave
Chicago, IL 60647
(773) 384-3333
Mon11am-10pm
Tue11am-10pm
Wed11am-10pm
Thu11am-10pm
Fri11am-11pm
Sat11am-11pm
Sun11am-10pm
Lincoln Park
Lincoln Park
2435 N Halsted St
Chicago, IL 60614
(872) 335-4868
HoursCheck website
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

7.3/10 - Parson's is a Logan Square institution, with a patio that's become one of the neighborhood's most beloved warm-weather destinations and a menu of fried chicken and fish that keeps regulars coming back.

The Infatuation - Sam Faye
"

7.3/10 - The Lincoln Park location matches the Logan Square original in quality. 'Our favorite way to order their fried chicken is the thigh sandwich, which comes topped with slaw, American cheese, hot sauce, aioli, and pickles.'

The Infatuation - Josh Barnett
"

4.5 out of 5 stars from nearly 2,500 Google reviewers - the Double Smash Burger is among the customer favorites listed alongside the signature fried chicken and frozen Negroni slushy.

Google Reviews
"

'While a smash burger has been added to the lineup in recent years, the majority of the menu riffs on the signature items' - the fried chicken and fish sandwiches that made Parsons a Chicago staple since 2013.

Resy Blog
"

9/10 on Foursquare - one of the highest Foursquare scores in the Chicago smash market, reflecting the strong local fanbase that has supported Parsons since 2013.

Foursquare
"

Yelp Logan Square - 1,200+ reviews (star rating pending verification). Reviewers note quality inconsistencies alongside praise for the fried chicken, patio, and Negroni slushy.

Yelp
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

No major list inclusions documented yet.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
✓Slagel Farms beef sourcing - same premium Illinois farm used by The Loyalist and Au Cheval - signals intentional ingredient quality
✓Two Infatuation reviews at 7.3/10 each (Logan Square and Lincoln Park) confirm consistent quality across locations
✓Google 4.5/5 from nearly 2,500 reviewers and Foursquare 9/10 reflect a strong and durable crowd consensus
✓Founded by the Longman & Eagle team (Michelin-starred gastropub) - institutional knowledge in running quality Chicago hospitality concepts
✓Cornmeal bun is a distinctive alternative to standard brioche - paired with Smokey 1000 Island for a house personality the burger doesn't share with competitors
✓Double Smash Burger at $15.95 is competitively priced for the Chicago smash market, especially given the beef sourcing
⚠ Caveats
✗NOT on The Infatuation's Best Smashburgers Chicago guide (15 restaurants) - a notable omission given two existing 7.3/10 location reviews
✗Neither Infatuation review mentions the smash burger - both focus on the fried chicken and fish; burger is a newer menu addition, not the restaurant's headline identity
✗Not featured in chibbqking, Burger Boyz 312, or Nick Murway's top burger lists - absent from Chicago's dedicated food enthusiast burger coverage
✗Yelp rating unconfirmed (rate-limited during collection) - quality inconsistencies reported in crowd reviews; restaurant known more for patio/cocktails than food
✗No Roscoe Village Burger Fest participation found