Certified SmashBucktown, ChicagoEst. 2020

The Leavitt Street Inn & Tavern

L. St. Smash
Bucktown, Chicago, Illinois·15 sources scored·Confidence: High
📍 2345 N Leavitt St, Chicago, IL 60647·📞 (773) 799-8093

The burger that helped launch Burger Boyz and later earned Chicago Magazine's top spot in their citywide burger quest. A double 1/3-pound smash with house pickles and signature sauce in Bucktown.

SmashburgerBucktownInn & TavernPatioChicago Magazine #1
Visit Website
Smash Score
82SMASH
SCORE
Certified Smash
#-- Nationally
National Ranking
#-- in Chicago
City Ranking
15 Sources
Scored Inputs
High
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

The Story

A Bucktown Corner Tavern Turned Burger Landmark.
Neighborhood-first hospitality, now a citywide burger draw.

Owners Sarah Brick and Teddy Harris opened The Leavitt Street Inn & Tavern in August 2020, converting Mickey's Tavern into a neighborhood gathering spot inside a historic 1907 Bucktown building. The concept pairs a tavern with three upstairs guest rooms for a local-stay experience.

Food service centered around the L. St. Smash, a double smashburger built from two 1/3-pound 80/20 Angus chuck patties. Chicago Magazine later ranked it #1 in their citywide burger quest, and multiple outlets highlighted its char level, house pickles, and sauce balance.

The result is a tavern burger with broad editorial coverage, strong community momentum, and a profile that keeps growing in Chicago's live rankings.

Context Note
The venue is an inn-and-tavern format rather than a burger-only concept. This score tracks the smashburger itself within that broader hospitality setting.
Score Breakdown

How the 82 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
77
Crowd 45% weight
97
Community 10% weight
84
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
80.06
QUALITATIVE BOOST
+2
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
Final score formula: 80.06 raw weighted average + 2 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 82.
The Burger

L. St. Smash

🥩
Build
Double smash, 2 x 1/3 lb 80/20 Angus chuck patties
🧀
Cheese
American
🍞
Bun
Sesame seed bun
🥕
Toppings
Caramelized onions, housemade pickles, house burger sauce
💵
Price
$15.00 (+$3 fries)
📍
Neighborhood
Bucktown
🔥
Operation
Bar & Restaurant / Inn Tavern
🍔
Established
2020
Two one-third-pound patties make this a notably large Chicago smash profile, and editorial coverage repeatedly calls out the sear, house pickles, and sauce execution.
Also on the Menu
Locations

Find The Leavitt Street Inn & Tavern

⭐ Original Location
The Leavitt Street Inn & Tavern
2345 N Leavitt St
Chicago, IL 60647
(773) 799-8093
MondayBar 3pm-1am | Kitchen 4pm-9pm
TuesdayBar 3pm-1am | Kitchen 4pm-9pm
WednesdayBar 3pm-1am | Kitchen 4pm-9pm
ThursdayBar noon-1am | Kitchen noon-9pm
FridayBar noon-1am | Kitchen noon-10pm
SaturdayBar noon-1am | Kitchen noon-10pm
SundayBar noon-1am | Kitchen noon-9pm
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

The meat is seared, with crispy edges, and seasoned right up to that edge of too much... it's perfect.

Chicago Magazine #1 Burger in Chicago
"

This hidden gem in Bucktown is home to the burger that started it all for Burger Boyz. The L. St. Smash Burger is a masterpiece.

Burger Boyz Masterpiece mention
"

This burger is best enjoyed on the outdoor patio with a beer in hand.

Time Out Chicago #7 of 14
"

The crispy smashburger patties are juicy, come with a healthy amount of tangy sauce and onions, and are served on a seared sesame bun.

The Infatuation Chicago
"

Anyone can enjoy the extensive selection of Midwestern beers and a spectacular smash burger topped with American cheese, caramelized onions, and housemade pickles.

Time Out Chicago
"

It is seriously so damn delicious, about as close to perfection as you can get. Arguably the best burger sauce I have ever tasted.

Burger Boyz
"

This corner bar is commonly mentioned when the city's best smashed burgers are discussed. The patties are smashed to perfection and a bit larger than typical.

chibbqking
"

The smashburger is the biggest draw of all... The absolute best smashed burger I have ever had.

TripAdvisor / Chicago Sun-Times Reader
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
Great Chicago Burger Quest - #1
2024 · Chicago Magazine
📋
Best Smashburgers in Chicago - #9
2025 · The Infatuation Chicago
📋
Best Restaurants in Bucktown - #15
2026 · The Infatuation Chicago
📋
14 Best Burgers in Chicago - #7
2026 · Time Out Chicago
📋
31 Best Restaurants in Wicker Park & Bucktown - #16
2024 · Time Out Chicago
📋
Chicago's Best Neighborhood Bars
2022 · Chicago Magazine
📋
Reader Nomination - Best Burger in Chicago
2026 · Chicago Sun-Times reader survey
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
#1 in Chicago Magazine's burger quest across 100+ burgers reviewed since 2020.
Two 1/3-pound patties deliver a larger smash format than many local peers.
Housemade pickles and signature sauce are repeatedly highlighted by reviewers.
Strong cross-outlet support from Chicago Magazine, Time Out, The Infatuation, and WGN-TV.
Google crowd signal remains exceptional at high volume in market context.
⚠ Caveats
Kitchen service starts later on weekdays, reducing lunch access early in the week.
Busy patio periods can produce longer wait times for burger orders.
No delivery-platform footprint; this is primarily an in-person destination.
No competition-award bonus currently applied in the scoring formula.
Yelp star-rating confirmation remains incomplete in the provided source set.