Certified Smash Est. 1918

The Workingman's Friend

Double Cheeseburger
Haughville, Indianapolis, IN · 12 sources scored · Confidence: High
📍 234 N. Belmont Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46222 · 📞 (317) 636-2067

Indianapolis's 100+ year smashburger institution. Named best burger in Indiana by Food & Wine, Thrillist, and First We Feast. Cash only, 21+, lunch hours only — plan ahead.

Smashburger Haughville Old-School Tavern Cash Only Lunch Only
Submit Update
Smash Score
81 SMASH
SCORE
✅ Certified Smash
12 Sources
Scored Inputs
High
Confidence
Last calculated April 2026
Algorithm v1.1

Representative photography. Actual appearance may vary.

The Story

Indianapolis's 100-Year Smash Original
A tavern classic built on the griddle.

The Workingman's Friend has been smashing burgers on the same flat-top since 1918 — long before smashburgers had a name. Louis Stamatkin, a Macedonian immigrant, opened the tavern in Indianapolis's Haughville neighborhood to feed local railroad workers. More than a century later, the Stamatkin family still runs it the same way: Tue–Sat lunch only, cash only, 21+, and a flat-top that hasn't changed since at least 1960.

The Double Cheeseburger is built differently than any other smashburger in Indianapolis. Two beef patties are smashed paper-thin on a griddle seasoned by decades of use, then assembled Big Mac-style on a three-section bun — heel, middle bun, crown — with American cheese melted onto each patty, shredded iceberg, and a thin spread of mayo. The result, as Food & Wine put it, is 'so smashed it's not even funny.' The burger is nearly all crispy lacy edge. That flat-top seasoning is not replicable.

Smash Atlas Context Note

The Workingman's Friend is a 21+ cash-only tavern with very limited lunch hours. The Smash Score reflects the Double Cheeseburger specifically, not convenience, sides, or the broader bar experience.

Score Breakdown

How the 81 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
84
Crowd 45% weight
90
Community 10% weight
79
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
78.68
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
12
Final score formula: 78.68 raw weighted average + +2 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 81.
The Burger

Double Cheeseburger

🥩
Build
Two paper-thin hand-smashed beef patties on a decades-seasoned flat-top
🧀
Cheese
American cheese melted onto each patty
🍞
Bun
Three-section Big Mac-style bun
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
Shredded iceberg lettuce, mayonnaise, crispy lacy edges
💵
Price
Price not confirmed from research. Estimated $9–12 based on customer reports of two burgers + sides totaling ~$34. Cash only.
💡
Neighborhood
Haughville
🔥
Operation
Bar & Restaurant
🍔
Established
1918
Food & Wine called it 'so smashed it's not even funny.' The flat-top has been in use since at least 1960 (when it was purchased used), and the decades of accumulated seasoning are considered part of the burger's flavor. The three-section bun structure — the distinctive Big Mac-style layer — is what sets it apart visually from every other Indianapolis smashburger. This is the original article; modern smashburger chains are doing what Workingman's Friend has done since 1918.
Locations

Find The Workingman's Friend

⭐ Haughville
The Workingman's Friend
234 N. Belmont Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46222
(317) 636-2067
MondayClosed
Tuesday11:00am–2:45pm
Wednesday11:00am–2:45pm
Thursday11:00am–2:45pm
Friday11:00am–2:45pm
Saturday11:00am–2:45pm
SundayClosed
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

So smashed it's not even funny, served Big Mac-style with bread in the middle, plus cheese on both patties, shredded iceberg, and a bit of mayonnaise spread thinly on the bun.

Food & Wine
"

This decidedly unfussy 21-plus tavern has been cooking up what may just be the city's most legendary burger for decades.

Indianapolis Monthly
"

Smashing the patties onto a grill top seasoned by the years creates those crispy, salty jagged edges we have come to love.

Indianapolis Monthly
"

A really thin burger that's more than half made of crispy edges. The burger was stellar.

Burgers, Barbecue and Everything Else
"

The juicy flavorful meat is really crispy on the edge and each thin patty is topped with melted cheese. A fantastic burger — the wait of close to an hour was worth it.

Dining With Frankie
"

Everything's cooked to order, everything's cut fresh. It still tastes the same, the exact same.

NUVO
"

Sides were mediocre — frozen fries and rings. Order a third burger instead.

Burgers, Barbecue and Everything Else
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
#1 Food & Wine — Best Classic Restaurants in Every State (Indiana)
2022 ? Named Indiana's best classic restaurant by major national food publication
🏆
#1 Thrillist — Best Burger in Every State (Indiana)
2015 ? Named Indiana's best burger in national 50-state roundup
📋
First We Feast — Best Smashburgers in America
2022 ? Named one of the country's best smashburgers by national food publication
🏆
#1 FOX59 — Indy's Best Burger
2022 ? Named Indy's Best Burger by local TV (in partnership with Indianapolis Monthly)
📋
Indianapolis Monthly — Indy Must-Eat Burger Spots
2025 ? Featured in the dominant Indianapolis food publication's dedicated burger guide
#1 Yelp — Best Cheeseburger Spot in Indiana
Yelp algorithmic designation as top cheeseburger restaurant in Indiana
🏆
#3 IndyStar Burger & Fries Bracket Challenge — Final Four
2024 ? Reached the Frynal Four (top 4 out of 16+) in IndyStar's public vote bracket; lost to 317 Burger in the semifinal
🏆
#2 INDYtoday Burger Bracket — Runner-Up
2023 ? Reached the championship final before losing to 317 Burger in a public vote bracket
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
Operating since 1918 — one of the oldest continually-operating smashburger institutions in the United States
Named best burger in Indiana by Food & Wine (2022), Thrillist (2015), First We Feast, Yelp, and multiple 'best in state' lists
The same flat-top griddle has been in use since at least 1960 — decades of accumulated seasoning are considered inseparable from the flavor
The three-section Big Mac-style bun structure is a genuinely unique build not found elsewhere in Indianapolis
Google rating of 4.6/5 across 1,666 reviews is exceptionally strong for a cash-only, 21+, lunch-only bar
Consecutive runner-up finishes in two separate Indianapolis burger bracket competitions (INDYtoday 2023, IndyStar 2024) confirm ongoing community esteem
⚠ Caveats
Extremely limited hours (Tue–Sat, 11am–2:45pm only) — plan carefully or you will miss it
Cash only, 21+ — a meaningful portion of customers cannot enter
Sides (fries, onion rings) receive routine criticism as frozen/mediocre — this is a one-thing restaurant
Nearly one-hour waits reported during peak lunch hours; no reservations possible
No official website, no delivery options, no online ordering — discovery and access are friction-heavy