Double smash cheeseburger at Natural State Provisions in Indianapolis
73Smash
Score
Smash Score👍 Solid Smash
Solid Smash Est. 2022

Natural State Provisions

Smash Burger
Holy Cross, Indianapolis, IN · 5 sources scored · Confidence: Medium ·Updated July 2026
Southern Comfort FoodDog-FriendlyLocal Beef

A classic, no-pretense smash burger from the King Dough team, made with local Indiana beef in a dog-friendly Holy Cross dive bar. Indianapolis Monthly-reviewed and featured in Indy's smashburger boom.

Smashburger Holy Cross
Visit Website
Smash Score
73 SMASH
SCORE
👍 Solid Smash
5 Sources
Scored Inputs
Medium
Confidence
Last calculated July 2026
Algorithm v1.1
The Story

Holy Cross Southern Comfort, Smashed
Local Indiana beef in a dog-friendly dive.

Natural State Provisions is the work of Adam and Alicia Sweet, the couple behind King Dough pizza, who turned a test kitchen in Fishers into a full-scale Holy Cross restaurant in 2022. The name nods to Arkansas - the Natural State - where Adam Sweet grew up, and the menu follows: sweet-tea-brined fried chicken, catfish, fried bologna, and a smash burger that earns its spot on the menu with Fisher Farms beef and Heirloom Acres tomatoes. The space is the old Flat12 / Rad Brewing building on Dorman Street, now filled with taxidermy, flour-sack art, and Pax Verum beer on tap.

Natural State Provisions uses local Indiana producers for its smash burger - Fischer Farms beef smashed on the griddle, Heirloom Acres tomatoes, American cheese, pickles, lettuce, onion, and house burger sauce. The smaller 'Twitty' build (a nod to Conway Twitty's country-Southern legacy) runs $9 on a sesame seed bun. Indianapolis Monthly called it 'as classic as can be' - a burger that fits the dog-and-dive-bar setting without trying to be anything it's not. Order the sweet potato fries and a Pax Verum draft alongside.

Smash Atlas Context Note

Natural State Provisions is a Southern comfort-food restaurant rather than a burger-first operation. Editorial coverage is credible, but critics generally position the smash burger as a solid supporting item instead of the kitchen's must-order dish.

Score Breakdown

How the 73 Was Calculated

Critics 35% weight
72
Crowd 45% weight
80
Community 10% weight
75
Accolades 10% weight
0
RAW WEIGHTED AVG
71.08
COMPETITION BONUS
+0
SOURCES SCORED
5
Final score formula: 71.08 raw weighted average + +1.5 qualitative boost + +0 competition bonus = 73.
The Burger

Smash Burger

🥩
Build
Fischer Farms beef patty smashed on the flattop; double available for +$2
🧀
Cheese
American cheese
🍞
Bun
Standard bun; sesame seed bun on the Twitty
🥕
Toppings & Sauce
Heirloom Acres tomato, lettuce, onion, pickle, burger sauce
💵
Price
$13
💡
Neighborhood
Holy Cross
🔥
Operation
Bar & Restaurant
🍔
Established
2022
The Smash Burger at NSP sources from local Indiana producers - Fischer Farms beef and Heirloom Acres tomatoes - giving it a farm-to-dive-bar character that fits the Arkansas-Southern concept. Indianapolis Monthly called it 'as classic as can be.' The Twitty Burger (named in the spirit of Conway Twitty, fitting the Southern roots) is a $9 option for a lighter build. The restaurant's must-order per Indy Monthly is actually the pulled pork sandwich, but the smash burger earns its place as a solid, unpretentious everyday option.
Locations

Find Natural State Provisions

⭐ Holy Cross
Natural State Provisions
414 Dorman St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
(317) 492-9887
MonClosed
TueClosed
Wed4pm-9pm
Thu4pm-9pm
Fri4pm-9pm
Sat12pm-9pm
Sun12pm-8pm
What Critics & Diners Say

Review Excerpts

"

The smash burger at this Holy Cross dog and dive bar is as classic as can be, with American cheese, tomato, lettuce, onion, pickles, and burger sauce.

Indianapolis Monthly
"

Brought to you by the minds behind King Dough, Natural State Provisions has an awesome southern-inspired menu including their rendition of the classic smashburger.

Taste Indianapolis
"

Real southern cooking has been a big hit.

Fox59
"

It's crowned with American cheese and chunky bread-and-butter pickles.

Indianapolis Monthly
"

Incredible beer and shot combinations, delicious sweet potato fries and unreal burgers like the double smashburger. Amazing patio too!

Yelp (customer review)
"

The Twitty burger was fire and came with homemade chips with an addicting seasoning.

Customer review (DoorDash/Yelp)
"

The Smash Burger was well-seasoned but was kinda dry.

Yelp (customer review)
Accolades & List Inclusions

The Record

📋
Indianapolis Monthly Indy Must-Eat Burger Spots - Featured
2025 · One of 5 restaurants in Indy Monthly's smashburger guide ('Taste Test: Indy's Smashburger Boom'), published May 2025.
📋
Indianapolis Monthly Review - ★★/4 Stars
2022 · Full editorial review by Julia Spalding (Dec 2022). 2 out of 4 stars overall for the restaurant.
📋
Taste Indianapolis Best Smashburgers Guide - Featured
2023 · One of 6 restaurants in Taste Indianapolis's dedicated smashburger guide.
Our Assessment

Strengths & Caveats

✓ Strengths
✓Two separate Indianapolis Monthly editorial touchpoints - standalone restaurant review and burger guide inclusion
✓Uses local Indiana producers: Fischer Farms beef and Heirloom Acres tomatoes
✓Solid Yelp crowd scores (4.0/5, 115 reviews) - strong community reception
✓Dog-friendly patio and dog park make it a genuine neighborhood destination
✓From Adam Sweet of King Dough - an established and trusted Indy restaurateur
✓The 'Twitty' $9 smash option provides an accessible entry point
✓Genuine Southern-Arkansas backstory gives the concept authenticity and character
⚠ Caveats
✗Indy Monthly primary review gives the restaurant only 2/4 stars - the smash burger is not the must-order
✗Best items per critics are the pulled pork sandwich and fried chicken, not the burger
✗At least one customer review flagged the smash burger as 'kinda dry'
✗Limited hours (closed Mon-Tue; Wed-Fri evenings only) restrict accessibility
✗Mirror Indy (Liz Biro - most credentialed Indy food critic), IndyStar, and Eater have not covered the restaurant
✗No Google Maps rating confirmed